by schn4rk » Thu Feb 16, 2012 3:17 am
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('WarheadsSE', 'T')he real issue here is that the u-boot does not have access to the USB3.0 ports (blue), thus it is unusable.
Just to clarify - I understand that, the issue is just that if you go through the install process with the USB stick in one of those back ports, uboot won't be able to boot from the top USB 2.0 port either. That's why it's necessary to then revert the plug and start from scratch. It's an issue several of us have experienced - a minor issue to be sure, and I don't mean to say there is anything wrong with uboot or alarm, but this thread wouldn't exist if a few of us hadn't experienced it.
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('kmihelich', 'I') don't see how the instructions are anything but perfectly clear, as the SATA port is mentioned twice in the same line as "USB 2.0" in context with "top," in the context of "the device" as seen on the main page has no other possible meaning than the actual top of the device. The back is not, obviously, the top of the device. Also worth noting is that USB 3.0 ports are very much blue, which unless you're unfortunately colorblind, is a stark contrast to the black that has been seen for the last decade. There's a point to dumbing down instructions where we have to draw a line, and this would be one of them. We used to do things like use bold, change colors, fonts, italicize, and it has been proven that no matter how succinctly we describe an operation with any number of cosmetic enhancements to further emphasize, points will be missed.
I apologise if my post gave the impression that I thought the instructions aren't clear. The fact that only a few of us have had this problem proves how clear they are, and how issue-free the install process is. I honestly didn't want to sound ungrateful!
That said, a subtle rephrasing of only one line would help avoid any more misunderstandings. Currently it states at the beginning: "Only the top ports (USB 2.0 and SATA) can be used for the root filesystem." I propose the following change: "Only the USB 2.0 and SATA ports on the top of the device can be used for the root filesystem."
Anyway, it's just a suggestion, it's a minor issue, and it's the only criticism I have. I really want to stress that I am very grateful for all the hard work you guys have put, and continue to put, into developing alarm & uboot for all these devices. I appreciate how frustrating it can be when people ask dumb questions and make demands all the time as if you owe them something, it's probably a thankless task a lot of the time. So... thank you